Market Ignores Apple’s Earnings Pessimism – Bears Be Warned (Rating Upgrade) (NASDAQ:AAPL)

Apple Inc. (NASDAQ:AAPL) investors have faced a challenging three to four months since AAPL topped out in mid-July 2023. However, Apple Bears should be careful about claiming victory just yet, as AAPL is still up more than 22% over the past year on a total return basis. It outperformed the S&P 500’s (SPX) (SPY) 19% total return over the same period, suggesting a bearish view on AAPL hasn’t been on point.

I last updated AAPL holders in early September, as the company prepared to launch its iPhone 15. I maintained my caution in AAPL even as investors were assessed to have rotated back into the stock. However, the subsequent broad market pullback also impacted buying sentiments in AAPL, as the initial buying surge faded. Despite that, I assessed increasingly constructive buying sentiments since then, suggesting it’s timely to reassess whether the current levels are apt for buyers to add exposure, following its recent earnings release.

AAPL’s expensive valuation (rated “F” by Seeking Alpha Quant) is likely increasingly challenging to justify, given a marked slowdown in iPhone growth tailwinds. Accordingly, Apple reported a mixed fiscal fourth quarter or FQ4’23 earnings scorecard. While its growth in the US seems to have stabilized, its growth has stalled in China as revenue fell 2.5%, suggesting Apple wasn’t immune to the macroeconomic headwinds in China. Despite that, management stressed that Apple outperformed its peers in China, corroborated by Counterpoint Research, as “the overall smartphone market in China declined by 3% in CQ3.” Notwithstanding the outperformance, I believe AAPL’s growth premium suggests the market needs more confidence in a faster growth cadence to justify its valuation.

Apple Bears would likely point out that the significant slowdown in Mac revenue was disappointing, as it fell 33.8% YoY. However, management clarified that the comparison with last year’s metric needs to be considered in the correct context. Accordingly, management stressed that the ongoing “challenging market conditions” exacerbated the relatively poor performance, as last year’s “record” performance was boosted by “demand recapture” from earlier supply chain disruptions.

Digitimes’s recent reporting suggests that the demand signals in the notebook supply chain are mixed. However, the launch of Apple’s M3 chips powering the Mac could drive a more meaningful recovery in 2024. While it isn’t targeted at M2 chip users, investors should pay close attention to the interest from M1 chip users, as “the upgrade will result in a noticeable performance boost.”

Investors are likely assessing Apple’s ability to outperform Wall Street’s estimates in its December quarter (FQ1’24), as it’s Apple’s most crucial calendar quarter. The iPhone upgrade cycle (nearly 50% of Apple’s revenue base) faced challenges in CQ3. However, Apple still outperformed the US market’s smartphone decline. In addition, the figures were primarily based on Apple’s performance before its iPhone 15 series launch. As such, we will likely only be able to assess iPhone 15’s performance when Apple reports its first fiscal quarter release early next year.

Despite that, the market was likely disappointed with Apple’s guidance, as it expects flat sales in the December quarter, underperforming analysts’ estimates. As such, Apple’s near-term performance is still affected by its most successful hardware product. Although Apple’s services segment delivered a 16% YoY growth in FQ4, it accounted for only about 25% of Apple’s FQ4 revenue base. As a result, challenges in Apple’s iPhone category are still expected to dominate investors’ skepticism about how AAPL’s growth premium can still be justified.

Notwithstanding the relatively mixed demand signals across Apple’s key revenue segments, I believe investors have already anticipated these headwinds.

Accordingly, AAPL buyers have attempted to bottom out at its October lows, in line with its 50-week moving average or MA (blue line). However, AAPL has a long-term bearish signal at its July 2023 high ($200 level), which is expected to be its long-term top for a while.

As such, I see a tactical opportunity to go long on AAPL, as the Tim Cook-led company has proved its execution prowess against its peers, notwithstanding its high valuation.

The market seems confident in AAPL’s ability to deliver the goods in an increasingly challenging macroeconomic environment. However, if you choose to add, I urge investors to avoid adding close to AAPL’s $200 zone to improve their risk/reward. Also, if AAPL fails to hold its October 2023 lows ($165 level), a further breakdown toward its early March 2023 lows ($145 level) must be expected.

Rating: Upgraded to Cautious Buy.

Important note: Investors are reminded to do their due diligence and not rely on the information provided as financial advice. Please always apply independent thinking and note that the rating is not intended to time a specific entry/exit at the point of writing unless otherwise specified.

We Want To Hear From You

Have constructive commentary to improve our thesis? Spotted a critical gap in our view? Saw something important that we didn’t? Agree or disagree? Comment below with the aim of helping everyone in the community to learn better!